Breathe in for nothing: an interpretative phenomenological analysis exploring the influence of a Pilates warm-up in singers. An overview of the study
Research on the use of Pilates for classical singers is limited, despite the well-documented benefits of this somatic (mind-body) exercise modality on the general public. This study sought to ascertain the mental, physical and vocal benefits of a Pilates warm-up on four university singing students and one professional singer using Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA). A Pilates warm-up for singers was taught to the participants over six weeks, with three workshops of five days each interspersed with home practice. The effects thereof were documented, before-and-after questionnaires (GAD-7, Becks Depression Inventory and the RAND 36-Item short-form quality of life survey instrument) were completed, heart rate measurements taken (to determine if the warm-up initiated a parasympathetic nervous system response) and three semi-structured interviews were conducted with each participant. A focus group was then held with the participants to discuss the effects of the regime. The lived experience of the participants’ use of the Pilates warm-up was analysed and together with the collected data, was grouped into sub-themes named: Singing; Wellbeing; Preparation for Singing/Preparing the Body to Sing; Tools; Resilience; Mindfulness; Mind-Body Communication; Nervous System; Strengthening the Body; Relaxation through Movement and Pilates Breathing. In the cyclical interpretative process of an IPA, these sub themes were then grouped to form the main themes of the study, namely: Tools; Nervous System and Singing.
The results showed an overall improvement in the quality of life as well as an increase in mindfulness and relaxation which benefitted all of the singers vocally in some way. Heart rate measurements and anxiety and depression scores showed a generally positive trend, although these results were inconclusive and require further study. The Pilates warm-up provided the singers with specific tools with which to address their various issues which had an impact on their singing. Performance preparation and posture were found to be enhanced, as well as reduced muscle tension, increased vocal range and improvements in stamina and breathing. This study highlights the potential benefits of the use of a Pilates warm-up for classical singers and the areas of research that should be undertaken to further delineate these benefits.
Asher, Veera Khare. 2009. “The olympic singer: Integrating Pilates training into the voice studio”. Thesis – Doctorate., Las Vegas:UN.
Atilgan, Esra, Devram Tarakci, and Fatma Mutluay. 2017. “Examining the postural awareness and flexibility changes in physical therapy students who took clinical Pilates class”. Pakistan journal of medical sciences, 33(3):640–644.
Azevedo, Ruben T, Nell Bennett, Andreas Bilicki, Jack Hooper, Fotinit Markopoulou, and Manos Tsakiris. 2017. “The calming effect of a new wearable device during the anticipation of public speech”. Scientific reports, 7(2285).
Beck, Aaron T. 2018. Beck’s Depression Inventory, Boston Medical Center (Questionnaire). [Online],Available:https://www.bmc.org/sites/default/files/For_Medical_Professionals/Pediatric_Resources/Pediatrics__MA_Center_for_Sudden_Infant_Death_Syndrome__SIDS_/Beck-Depression-Inventory- BDI.pdf Date of access: 14 Jan. 2018.
Buckmire, Robert and Clark Rosen. 2001. “On the voice: care of the singing voice: facts and fiction”. American choral journal, 41(9):51–54.
Dankbaar, Jan Willem and Frank A Pameijer. 2014. “Vocal cord paralysis: anatomy, imaging and pathology”. Insights imaging, 5:743–751.
Gilman, Marina, and Michael M Johns. 2017. “The effect of head position and/or stance on the self- perception of phonatory effort”. Journal of voice, 31(1):131.e1-131.e4.
Gross, Sally Anne and George Musgrave. 2017. Can music make you sick? A study into the incidence of musicians’ mental health. Part 2: Qualitative study and recommendations. [Westminster]:UW/MusicTank.[Online],Available:https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/q33qz/can-music-make-you-sick-part-2-qualitative-study-and-recommendations Date of access: 7 Jan. 2018.
Grossmann, Igor, Baljinder K Sahdra, and Joseph Ciarrochi. 2016. “A heart and a mind: self-distancing facilitates the association between heart rate variability, and wise reasoning”. Frontiers in behavioral neuroscience, 10(68):1–10.
La Pine, Peter R. 2008. “The relationship between the physical aspects of voice production and optimal vocal health”. Music educators journal, 94(3):24–29.
McCarther, Sean. 2012. “Effecting positive change: a manual for teachers of singing”. Thesis – Doctorate., Bloomington: IU.
Melton, Joan. 2001. “Pilates training and the actor/singer”. The Australian voice. [Online], Available: www.onevoicebook.com/sites/default/files/pdf/pilates.pdf. Date of access: 10 Feb. 2018.
Misins, Janis. 2012. “The skills of body control in the process of breathing during studies of singing”. Education in a changing society, 1:227–232.
Moore, Jason. 2016. What’s the difference? Heart rate variability vs. heart rate. [Online], Available: https://www.hrvcourse.com/hrv-demographics-fitness-level/ Date of access: 10 Feb. 2018.
Neely, Dawn Wells. 2012. “Body conscious: a comparative study of body awareness and body alignment methods for singers and for teachers integrating them into their teaching”. Thesis – Doctorate., Tuscaloosa: UA.
Peifer, Corinna, André Schulz, Hartmut Schächinger, Nicola Baumann, and Conny H. Antoni. 2014. “The relation of flow-experience and physiological arousal under stress – can u shape it?” Journal of experimental social psychology, 53:62–69.
Pietkiewicz, Igor, and Jonathan A. Smith. 2014. “A practical guide to using interpretative phenomenological analysis in qualitative research psychology”. Czasopismo psychologiczne – Psychological journal, 20(1): 7-14.
Pringle, J., Drummond, J., Mc Lafferty, E. & Hendry, C. 2011. “Interpretative phenomenological analysis: a discussion and critique”. Nurse researcher, 18(3):20–24.
Randall, Michael. 2011. “The physiology of stress: cortisol and the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis”. Dartmouth undergraduate journal of science. [Online], Available: http://dujs.dartmouth.edu /2011/02/the-physiology-of-stress-cortisol-and-the-hypothalamic-pituitary- adrenal- axis/#.WwxXhlOFNE7 Date of access: 9 June 2018.
RC (Rand Corporation). 2017. 36-Item short form survey instrument. [Online], Available: http://www.rand.org/health/surveys_tools/mos/36-item-short-form.html Date of access: 14 Jan. 2018.
Robinson, Lynne, Helge Fisher, Jacqueline Knox and Gordon Thomson. 2000. The official Body Control Pilates manual. London: Macmillan.
Searle, Sally and Cathy Meeus. 2001. Secrets of Pilates. London: Dorling Kindersley.
Smith, Jonathan A., and Mike Osborn. 2008. Interpretative phenomenological analysis. (In Smith, Jonathan A., ed. Qualitative psychology: a practical guide to research methods. 2nd ed. London: SAGE. p.53–80).
Smith, Jonathan A., Paul Flowers, and Michael Larkin. 2009. Interpretative phenomenological analysis. London: SAGE.
Spitzer, Robert L., Kurt Kroenke, Janet BW Williams, and Bernd Löwe. 2006. “A brief measure for assessing generalized anxiety disorder. The GAD-7”. Arch intern med, 166:10921097.[Online],Available:https://www.phqscreeners.com/sites/g/files/g10049256/f/201412/GAD7_English for South Africa.pdf Date of access: 5 Oct. 2019.
Vancini, Rodrigo L., Angeles BR Rayes, Claudio A Barbosa De Lira, Karine JS Sarro, and Marilia Santos Andrade. 2017. “Pilates and aerobic training improve levels of depression, anxiety and quality of life in overweight and obese individuals”. Arquivos de neuro-psiquiatria, 75(12):850–857.
Vendafreddo, Thomas Patrick. 2012. “A blended pedagogy: synthesizing best practices of opera and musical theatre programs to promote a holistic approach to training the singing actor”. Thesis – Masters., San Diego: SDSU
Weinstein, Netta, Kirk W Brown, and Richard M Ryan. 2009. “A multi-method examination of the effects of mindfulness on stress attribution, coping, and emotional well-being”. Journal of research in personality, 43:374–385.